Tips For Hiring Family Members As Employees

Thinking about hiring family members? Many small business owners grapple with this decision, wondering about the benefits and potential pitfalls. Let’s break it down.

Why Hire Family Members?

Financial Benefits

Hiring family members can offer significant financial perks. One of the biggest draws is the tax savings. For instance, if you hire your children, you can pay them a reasonable wage that’s tax-deductible for your business. This reduces your taxable income while providing your kids with a source of income that might be taxed at a lower rate, or not at all, depending on their earnings.

• Example: If you pay your child $12,000 a year, that’s $12,000 you can deduct from your business income, potentially saving you thousands in taxes.

Trust and Reliability

Family members often come with a built-in level of trust that’s hard to find in external hires. You know their work ethic, their strengths, and their weaknesses. This can translate into a more reliable workforce, which is crucial in a small business setting where every role is vital.

• Example: Hiring your sibling who you know is meticulous and trustworthy can ensure that your financial records are always in top shape.

Succession Planning

Thinking long-term? Hiring family members can be a strategic move for succession planning. By involving your family in the business, you can instill your business values and ensure that the next generation is ready to take the reins when the time comes.

• Example: Training your daughter to manage operations can prepare her to eventually take over the business, ensuring continuity and preserving your legacy.

Legal Considerations When Hiring Family Members

How to Comply with Labor Laws

You need to comply with federal and state labor laws. This includes adhering to minimum wage laws, overtime pay, and child labor laws if you’re hiring minors. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) lays out the basic requirements, but state laws can vary, so make sure you’re up to date.

• Example: In some states, you can hire your 15-year-old for certain tasks, but there are strict limits on the number of hours they can work and the types of jobs they can do.

What Are the Tax Implications?

Understanding the tax implications is crucial. Hiring family members can affect your payroll taxes differently depending on the relationship and business structure. For example, wages paid to your spouse are subject to income tax withholding and Social Security and Medicare taxes but not to FUTA taxes.

• Example: If you run a sole proprietorship and hire your child under 18, their wages are exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes, which can save you a significant amount.

Documentation and Record-Keeping

Don’t skimp on documentation. Keep thorough records to meet regulatory requirements and support any tax claims. This includes employment contracts, timesheets, and payroll records.

• Example: Use Homebase’s document storage capabilities to keep all necessary employment records organized and accessible, aiding in compliance and audit readiness.

How to Ensure Fair Treatment and Avoid Nepotism

How to Create Objective Hiring Processes

Start with clear job descriptions and standardized interview procedures. This helps ensure that family members are hired based on their qualifications, not their last name.

• Example: When hiring your cousin for a marketing role, make sure they go through the same interview process as any other candidate, and that their job description is well-defined.

How to Implement Anti-Nepotism Policies

Implementing anti-nepotism policies can help. Define relationships and boundaries clearly. This includes outlining who can be hired, under what circumstances, and what roles they can hold.

• Example: Your policy might state that family members cannot be in direct supervisory roles over one another to prevent conflicts of interest.

Practical Steps for Hiring Family Members

Determine Job Roles and Responsibilities

Assess your business needs and match skills to roles. This ensures that family members are contributing in meaningful ways and not just taking up space.

• Example: If your niece is great with numbers, consider hiring her as an assistant accountant rather than a customer service representative.

Document Employment Terms

Make everything official with employment contracts and work activity logs. This not only helps with compliance but also sets clear expectations.

• Example: Draft an employment contract outlining your brother’s role, responsibilities, and compensation. Use Homebase’s tools to keep track of his work hours and tasks.

How to Manage Payroll and Benefits for Family Members

Payroll processing is critical. Make sure you’re withholding the correct taxes and reporting earnings accurately. Family members should be treated like any other employee when it comes to payroll to avoid any legal complications.

• Example: Use Homebase Payroll to automatically calculate wages, taxes, and deductions, ensuring everything is compliant and above board.

Benefits can also be a gray area. Offering tax-free fringe benefits like health insurance or retirement contributions can be a great way to compensate family members without increasing their taxable income.

• Example: If you hire your spouse, consider offering health insurance as a fringe benefit, which is tax-free and beneficial for both of you.

Timesheet accuracy is non-negotiable. Use a reliable system to track work hours and ensure fair compensation. This helps in maintaining transparency and avoiding any potential disputes.

• Example: Implement Homebase’s time clock feature to track when family members clock in and out, ensuring accurate timesheets and payroll.

​​

Best Practices for Onboarding Family Members

How to Set Clear Expectations

Setting clear expectations from day one is crucial. Outline their responsibilities, performance metrics, and what success looks like in their role. This helps in aligning their personal and professional goals with the business objectives.

• Example: During the onboarding session, make it clear that while they are family, they are also expected to meet the same performance standards as other employees.

How to Provide Training and Development

Training and development are key to integrating family members into your business effectively. Offer skill enhancement programs and regular feedback sessions to help them grow in their roles.

• Example: Set up a training program that includes both job-specific skills and general business knowledge, ensuring they are well-rounded and capable.

Regular evaluations help in tracking progress and addressing any issues early on. This ensures that family members are continually improving and contributing effectively to the business.

• Example: Use Homebase’s employee happiness tools to conduct anonymous surveys and track performance metrics, ensuring a positive and productive work environment.

Addressing Common Challenges in Family Employment

How to Handle Conflicts

Conflicts are inevitable, but how you handle them makes all the difference. Implement conflict resolution strategies and consider mediation techniques to keep things professional.

• Example: If a disagreement arises between family members, address it promptly and professionally, perhaps involving a neutral third party to mediate.

How to Balance Family and Business Dynamics

Balancing family and business can be tough. Set clear boundaries to maintain professionalism and avoid letting personal relationships interfere with business operations.

• Example: Establish rules about discussing business during family gatherings to ensure that work issues don’t spill over into personal time.

Maintaining professionalism is crucial. Treat family members as you would any other employee, with the same expectations, responsibilities, and consequences.

• Example: If a family member isn’t meeting performance standards, address it just as you would with any other employee, using objective criteria and documented performance reviews.

Is Hiring Family Members Right for Your Business?

So, is hiring family members the right move for your business? It depends on your specific circumstances. Assess the pros and cons carefully, considering both the personal and professional impacts.

• Pros: Financial benefits, trust, reliability, and succession planning.
• Cons: Potential for conflicts, accusations of favoritism, and the challenge of maintaining professionalism.

Ultimately, the decision should align with your business goals and family dynamics. If done right, hiring family members can be a win-win situation, benefiting both your business and your family.

By following these guidelines, you can make informed decisions about hiring family members, ensuring a harmonious and productive work environment. And remember, tools like Homebase can make the process smoother, from payroll to compliance, helping you focus on what truly matters—growing your business.

Real-World Examples and Additional Tips

Align Family Members’ Strengths with the Right Position

Hiring a family member can be a perfect solution for filling a position that requires someone you trust, like bookkeeping or cash handling. Family members may also be the best option for hard-to-fill positions. Proceed with caution, however, because sometimes the very fact that you are family can mean that you can be blind to character flaws and could still be vulnerable to theft and embezzlement.

Give Your Children Space to Fail and Learn

At the Queens Cups, a bakery in Massachusetts, a husband and wife team work for their daughter who started the business a few years ago. Barbara (the mother) says that the recipe for success is to allow your children the space to make their own decisions. Although she and her husband (who has a background in the food industry) give their advice, ultimately the final decision is their daughter’s. Queens Cups is doing incredibly well, but for Barbara, it is not easy to watch your children make decisions that are different from how you would have made them.

Working with family may require prioritizing relationships over your ideal business decision. To work with family members, you have to let go and give them the space to fail. We become wise through failure. Watching your children fail is a part of being a parent. Watching your child fail in business can be excruciating. However, it’s important to think about your past failures and remember the life lessons they taught you. Enlist someone from the outside as a mentor for your relative so that you don’t bear the sole responsibility for steering family members on the right course.

Sideline a Bad Employee

Family members destroy businesses far too often when the owner or manager doesn’t want to face the reality that their relative cannot perform. In the small business space, I advised many family business owners who needed to carve out a role for a relative who could not cut it as an employee. As you can imagine, employee morale and teamwork breaks down when employees believe that the relative has not earned their position.

Tasks like social media, networking, and developing community partnerships can keep that family member out of the office and away from irritated employees. By allowing that person to continue in a position where they are not adding value, you are multiplying the negative impact on your business. Cut your losses and create a role where the relative will be as least destructive as possible.

Terminate With Caution

Letting an employee go is never easy. But letting go of a member of your own or of another employee’s family is extra tricky. It’s often most difficult after the troublesome employee leaves, if other family members remain. If you terminate an employee’s family member, you may destroy trust and respect between the remaining employee and the manager, and it will likely result in needing to replace all relatives that you have been employing.

You must let relatives know before hiring their family member that poor performance may lead to termination, and they should only provide references for family members they know can perform.

Managing family is a delicate situation that requires less business and leadership knowledge and more personal relationship and conflict management skills. The relationship will never simply be employee to employee. It will always be a family relationship first.

A Double Edged Sword

Hiring family members can be a double-edged sword, offering both significant benefits and potential challenges. By understanding the legal, financial, and practical aspects, and by implementing fair and transparent policies, you can navigate this complex terrain successfully. Use tools like Homebase to streamline the process and focus on what truly matters—growing your business and maintaining healthy family relationships.